Longtime readers will recall that I wrote the following in June:

Trust building activities may register high on the radar screens of the organizations Winning Workplaces [has honored], but on the whole among the roughly 27 million small businesses across the U.S., they do not.  These and other human capital strategies are considered by many leaders to be "soft," and therefore, in a down economy, not worth leadership's time and energy compared with other areas of the business.

Maybe the results of Deloitte's latest Ethics & Workplace Survey will change some minds regarding the ROI of building trust in the workplace.  Surveying more than 700 employed Americans in April, Deloitte found that close to half have lost trust in their employer since the start of the recession; this has propelled more than a third of respondents to look for a new job as the economy picks up.

Certainly, some leaders are hip to and worried about these trends; those who run our Top Small Company Workplaces are among them.  As Management-Issues notes today, the same survey from Deloitte found that

Two-thirds of Fortune 1000 executives who are concerned employees will be job hunting in the coming months acknowledge that trust will be a factor in any increase in voluntary turnover....

The results of this survey make me wonder how much lower the percentage of employees looking to bolt would be if more companies had tried to share the pain in the midst of the worst of this recession, instead of pulling the layoff trigger first.  I also wonder – and maybe future studies will put some quantifiable data behind this – how much more revenue small and other businesses that did not view worker trust as a priority during the apex of the crisis might have right now.  The answer to this question has larger implications, including on our current GDP level and jobless rate.

Related: In April I profiled six small businesses in our network that turned to employee furloughs and pay cuts instead of layoffs to weather tough times, and came out stronger for their decision.  Read their stories here.

Last month on TIME magazine's Curious Capitalist blog, Barbara Kiviat, citing the New York Times, argued that because

Hundreds of thousands of Americans have enrolled in federally financed training programs in recent years, only to remain out of work ... job retraining is a wash.

This position may make sense from a policymaker or an economist's point of view – and in fact the Curious Capitalist blog carries a tagline saying it's about the economy and markets as much as it is business.

Yet, based on the evidence we see from the applications for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, small business leaders don't view retraining as a wash.  However, most* do keep tabs on it as a measurement of their failure to attract and retain the best people while aligning those people with the company's needs and deploying effective employee leadership development strategies.

In other words, while they value retraining, they see it as an employee educational investment of last resort.

Consider the responses to our essay question on how people practices contribute to the top line revenue and bottom line profitability from the following three companies:

KeyLogic Systems, Inc., West Virginia:
"At KeyLogic our product IS our people; which we hire through strong recruitment and employee referral programs.  We have a low turnover ratio which has impacted both the top line revenue (allowing for employee to customer continuity) and bottom line profitability by allowing us to focus more on developing our current employee resources through professional training as opposed to the high cost of recruiting, re-training and developing new employees."

Prenova, Georgia:
"Since our managers and executives interact with lower-level employees, they can impart much of their knowledge and information on an as-needed basis, rather than waiting for issues to be discovered (often because of a costly emergency) and spending large amounts of time and labor developing ways to distribute that information. Conversely, employees can quickly and easily access other team members capable of discussing issues, and receive retraining when necessary."

Pro CNC Inc., Washington State:
"Being very thorough in our hiring practices has also led to extremely low turn-over which certainly has an effect on profitability and revenue.  We don't spend a lot of time retraining new hires and can focus on the business of serving our customers."

*I should note that a few firms we've come across – as part of our workplace award as well as our consulting and speaking engagements – don't view retraining as an if-needed effort.  These rare enterprises actively budget for this as part of their staff engagement activities, looking to help those who want to continue working for the company, but in a different area.  They see retraining as a means to hold onto this talent and keep using them to drive results.

Related: Read our review of A Manager's Guide to Coaching, which is aimed at helping organizations decrease their time and money spent on recruiting in addition to retraining.

I don't yet have it in my hands, but I already know I'm going to like the latest book from workplace generational expert Neil Howe, Millennials in the Workplace.

According to StreetInsider.com, Howe "turns [the] downbeat message [from the media on Millennials, aka Generation Y] on its head."  Taking the position that Millennials are an asset and opportunity rather than a lazy (insert other adjectives here) liability, the website writes, Howe's new book serves in part as a resource for employee engagement and team building strategies to find and keep them.

Providing a sample of the employee retention tips Howe shares in Millennials, StreetInsider.com links to this pdf from Howe's company, LifeCourse.  At its core is the following list of recruiting and retention strategies tailored to this young generation that, some reports say, became the most pervasive one of all this year: 

1. Treat them like VIPs
2. Co-recuit the parents
3. Find them early
4. Look after them
5. Offer structure and teach them the basics
6. Provide tight cycles of feedback
7. Don't offer a "McJob"
8. Make them part of the group
9. Be active in the community
10. Take an interest in their success

I really like that the pdf includes a section on "What To Do" under each of the above strategies to take them from the world of the ambiguous to the practical.

Given the Millennial workforce's size and its stature as the dominant generation in the work world for years to come, it's no surprise that our Top Small Company Workplaces are already using many of the above strategies to help them tackle pressing issues from process and supply chain improvement to sales lead cultivation and delivery.

Related: Read my 4 reasons why Millennials may be the ones to pull us out of our troubled economy.

In a recent post on The Wall Street Journal's The Juggle blog, Jennifer Merritt asked if Summer Fridays still exist.  The "still" part of her question is informed by the realities of the economy forcing companies to cut benefits such as a part or full workday off, and companies that are tight on staff (again because of the economy) needing all the time they can get to best serve the customer or client.

In response to Merritt's question, Summer Fridays do, in fact, still exist.  Among the nearly 500 applicants for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, 8 specifically referred to reduced hours or a full day off on Fridays during the summer in their applications:

1. The Leadership and Learning Center - consulting firm in Salem, MA
2. Sonoma Partners - software firm in Chicago, IL
3. McGraw Wentworth* - insurance benefits provider in Troy, MI
4. Family Heritage Life Insurance Company - financial services firm in Cleveland, OH
5. NogginLabs Inc - software firm in Chicago, IL
6. Maxons Restorations, Inc. - property damage restoration services provider in New York, NY
7. Rauxa Direct - advertising firm in Costa Mesa, CA
8. Affect Strategies - PR/marketing firm in New York, NY

*This company is a 2010 award finalist

In addition, a review of our 2010 applicants shows that many of them offer the following activities for employee engagement and team building on Fridays (in all seasons):

1. Happy hour
2. Healthy breakfast items – most commonly fruits and bagels
3. Staff lunch
4. Casual dress
5. Yoga
6. Massages
7. Fun run
8. "Praise Box" – measure to reward hard work with awards and prizes
9. Staff outings during sport seasons – most commonly football
10. Friday night movies

Think these Friday-themed people practices are just a waste of money?  Consider that another 2010 applicant, B2B sales training services firm Vorsight in Arlington, VA, told us that, "When we put in place our Friday company lunch and one on one coaching, top line revenue jumped 20%."

What other Friday practices do you do, or have you heard about?

Today I shared with our Twitter followers a how-to series of posts the Young Entrepreneur blog is running on starting a business.  One of these posts I found interesting is Adam Toren's piece on choosing a business legal/tax structure.  He helps budding entrepreneurs greatly by rating the pros and cons of structures including Sole Proprietorship, Joint Venture, Limited Partnership, Limited Liability Company, and C and S Corporations.

Reading Toren's post inspired me to take a look at the data Winning Workplaces has on the small business applicants for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, in terms of revenue and profitability for the legal/tax structures we looked at under our criteria of evaluating privately held and not-for-profit organizations.  The legal/tax structures of the firms we assessed included:

• C Corporation (roughly 3/10 firms)
• S Corporation (roughly 5/10 firms)
• Partnership/Proprietorship (roughly 2/10 firms)

Here's how they break down by structure for both average 2009 revenue and percentage that were profitable in 2009:

*Assumes the firm has been in business at least 3 years

The key takeaway is that while C Corps edged out the other two structures in revenue, a greater share of Partnership/Proprietorships are profitable.

You may be asking, What makes this survey sample a good one to use these metrics for benchmarking purposes?  Well, beyond the size of the sample (497 organizations) and the fact that they have all crossed the Dun & Bradstreet threshold of surviving after the first three years, most of these enterprises understand the payoff of employee engagement and team building strategies on the bottom line.  So they post better revenue and profitability numbers to shoot for than a survey sample in which employees are more likely to be actively disengaged.

What's your take on the above?  How do you see strong people practices factoring into the equation?

If you have 90 minutes to spare, I have something that's a great use of your time when it comes to expanding your understanding of the payoff of employee engagement and workplace team building activities.

Below is a video of our President's presentation last month at an Entrepreneurial Roundtable hosted by the University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

If you can't see the video in your RSS reader, click here.

The presentation kicks off with our own Gaye van den Hombergh explaining why companies should care about creating great workplaces (starting at 7:30) and the qualities we see as critical to Winning Workplaces, along with some of the people practices used by winners of our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, which were featured in the June issue of Inc. Magazine (starting at 29:00).

Starting at 44:00, Gaye led a panel featuring leaders of this year's two Chicago area winners: Marvin Klein, Founder, PortionPac Chemical Corporation; and Tom Walter, President & CEO and Tasty Catering.  As you absorb the lessons learned and insights of these two leaders, consider their workplace culture practices, which I've listed below respectively, that have led them to success – even in this tough economy:

PortionPac

Selected workplace best practices:

• Offers personal and financial support for employees on a case by case basis
• "Front to Back Day"
• Offers experience to improve personal confidence and communication skills
• Employees have a high degree of autonomy

Business results:

• 2009 revenue up 7% from 2008
• Over the same period their competitors suffered double digit losses

Tasty Catering

Selected workplace best practices:

• Personal financial crisis fund fed into by employees
• Healthy free meals provided to staff on a daily basis
• If an employee comes up with idea and is willing to put in the effort, the company will help finance and support the endeavor

Business results:

• While sales fell in 2009 vs. 2008, it experienced only half the decrease of its industry and remains profitable
• High average employee tenure of 7.5 years

What are your takeaways from watching this video?

In a post on the Business Insider blog re-posted from his own blog, GRP Partners' Mark Suster argues that leaders should solve problems and drive innovation from the top.  He writes,

I challenge you to consider whether you’re top-down or bottom up.  In analysis there are always circumstances for each approach.  But in leadership and entrepreneurism the top-down approach will be the right solution more often than not.

Now, I get that Suster is not saying that leaders should engage employees from the top down 100% of the time, but he is saying it should happen this way the majority of the time.

However, in our experience conducting employee engagement research of small businesses as part of our annual workplace award program, we see that management and decision making can happen in many different ways to lead companies to success in the metrics that ultimately matter: sales and profitability.  Our President detailed four decision-making approaches that run this gamut in these two posts.

Three of the four approaches she wrote about involve bottom-up decision making in some capacity.  And in fact, in the applications we received for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, we saw bottom-up engagement factor prominently in the qualitative feedback of some firms that are performing quite well, even in this tough economy. 

Check out four case studies that bear this out below.  All four companies have been profitable in the last three years.

Application Question: How have your organization’s people practices contributed to your top line revenue and bottom line profitability?
Response by Bronto Software
8-year-old software firm from North Carolina
2009 sales: $5.1 million; 132% 3-year sales growth
At Bronto we have a sales team who is instrumental to our success.  Because of our organic funding, growth comes from bottom up.  Employees have directly influenced consistent new client growth along with amazing client retention.

Application Question: How does the organization encourage employees to participate in important business decisions?
Response by Barhorst Insurance Group
17-year-old financial services firm from Texas
2009 sales: $6.9 million; 16% 3-year sales growth
Our organization is built on a foundation of bottom up planning!  Every year we have the branch managers provide a sales and expense plan that is fed into our annual corporate plan.  In 2008 and 2009 we completed or long term 2020 strategy to grow from 50 million in sales to 1 billion in sales.  The strategy team was comprised of 10 mid level associates from each department.  The team received feedback from their peers and developed a strategic road map for the future.  This plan includes monthly and quarterly progress reports to the leadership team.  The strategy team will begin rotating new team members through in 2010.  By using a bottom up method employees take ownership for the company's success and failure.

Response by Intermark Media
11-year-old advertising firm from New York
2009 sales: $92.7 million; 161% 3-year sales growth
At Intermark Media we believe changes in the company should be driven from the bottom up.  The employees who are interacting with our clients everyday have valuable insight into what processes work well and what changes need to be made to better meet the needs of our customers.  We encourage all employees to be a part of our decision making process at Intermark Media.  Weekly team meetings allow employees to voice opinions, discuss new ideas and solve problems.  Team leaders encourage input from each and every team member.  In addition to weekly meetings, leaders communicate daily through their email group to vote on awards, discuss ideas and concerns and get feedback.

Application Question: Over the last year, what kind of impact has the economy had on your business?
Response by Man-Machine Systems Assessment
20-year-old consulting firm from the District of Columbia
2009 sales: $8.6 million; 5% 3-year sales growth
The economy has little effect on our business.  We have continued to grow in spite of the economy and I truly believe this is because of the way we operate our business and the culture we have created.  MSA employees feel safe, and know that the owners will do everything within their power to provide work, support their needs, and care for them and their families.  This kind of loyalty is earned, and not bought.  The MSA family is strong and the support we have for one another from the top down to the bottom up allows for strength and faith as we face challenges, like the economy.

Related: We tackled bottom-up staff engagement activities in greater detail with the help of CEOs from two of our previously honored small firms in this webinar.

The following is a guest post on workplace team building and employee engagement by Steve Ritter.  Ritter, the Founder and CEO of Team Clock Institute, is the former Director of HR at Leaders Bank, which was named the #1 Best Place to Work in Illinois in 2006, and was a finalist for Winning Workplaces' Top Small Workplaces award in 2008.

Growing up, most of us are taught how to succeed as individuals.  Unfortunately, individual talent and dedication alone are not nearly enough to ensure a team’s success.  Teams are messy.  Conflict is unavoidable. Team dynamics are fluid.  Despite these challenges, working in teams is fundamental to most endeavors.

Twenty-five years ago, I began the quest of understanding the complexities of teams following a happenstance opportunity with the Chicago White Sox.  At the time, a seemingly strong team was underperforming for reasons beyond the grasp of their leadership.  Unexpectedly, a complex situation ended up having a simple solution.  Since then, identifying the recipe for healthy and effective teams has been my passion giving rise to the founding of the Team Clock Institute, a research and training consultancy specializing in breakthrough teams.  Recently, the Team Clock Institute responded to a unique challenge.

The Issue: Early in 2010, I received a call from a FORTUNE 500 company facing the integration of disparate cultures following the acquisition of a prominent player in the industry.  All of the expectable merger/acquisition politics were underway and the leadership team was seeking a simple model to anchor the transition.  What began as a casual conversation on a commuter train grew into an opportunity to assess the integration effort and provide recommendations to enhance successful business outcomes.

The Response: Accordingly, the Team Clock model was introduced to key players on the leadership team. The Team Clock model mirrors the face of a clock where each hour represents a stage along the path of team development.  In a nutshell, strong teams begin with an investment in common norms and direction.  Based on this foundation, team members test trust as they become more cohesive.  This platform supports their efforts to be innovative and take risks.  This activity inevitably leads to change and a repositioning of people and functions.  Healthy teams find a way to refocus following such growth and cycle begins again. 

The Impact: Over the next six months, the Team Clock Institute assessed a series of key business units to determine opportunities for greater effectiveness.  Results were analyzed revealing the strengths, vulnerabilities, areas of congruence and discord on the team.  Debriefing sessions were facilitated to discuss results and targeted actions were identified that would bring measurable change in team engagement and productivity.

Typical examples of diagnostic vulnerabilities included:

• Mired in loss: too depleted to re-invest.
• Inability to manage conflict/differences respectfully.
• Indulgence in the comfort zone: afraid to take risks and explore new ideas.
• Adherence to the status quo: unwilling to accept the consequences of change.

From a strengths perspective, the Team Clock Institute identified key anchors to healthy team interactions based on the diagnostic results for each team.  Goals were established in each of the core areas of vulnerability and business metrics were assigned to determine ROI.  The goal areas included:

• Investment infrastructure

- Consensus philosophy/mission/values/vision

• Trust and interactional dynamics

- Effective management of conflict

• Innovation and team effectiveness

- Measureable productivity/efficiency shifts

• Distancing to leverage change for growth

- Functional repositioning and identification of new opportunities/methodologies

The business case for effective teaming is simple.  Healthy teams are more productive and adaptable.  Anticipating the 4th quarter of the calendar year, the organization is poised to re-assess their team effectiveness metrics mapped to their productivity results.  Pending the quantitative impact, the qualitative result is clear: the emotional journey of a healthy team provides opportunities for positive workplace culture that struggling teams rarely experience.  Where is your team on the Team Clock?

Learn more about all of the resources at the Team Clock Institute at www.team-clock.com.

I wanted to share with you two upcoming events for which Winning Workplaces is a promotional partner.  You will surely gain valuable insights at both of them to help you implement employee engagement and team building activities for a more productive workplace – especially at the latter event, whose programming is all about that.

SJF Summit on the New Green Economy: Early Bird registration ends this week

What: SJF Summit on the New Green Economy
When: September 14-15, 2010
Where: Durham Marriott Convention Center, Durham, NC
Event Website: www.sjfsummit.org

Register now for SJF's second annual Summit on the New Green Economy: Accelerating Growth and Impact.  The SJF Summit will be a dynamic gathering of entrepreneurs, investors, government and community leaders  sharing inspiring successes & practical tools and exploring strategic partnerships to build the green economy with opportunities for all.  The event will feature keynotes from Bruce Usher, former CEO of carbon trading firm EcoSecurities, and David Orr, distinguished professor at Oberlin College describing the innovative Oberlin green economy initiative, as well as many more.  There will also be a Cleantech CEO panel and concurrent sessions on the latest in cleantech investing, emerging capital market innovations, green jobs and green economic development strategies, and carbon markets.

Creating Competitive Cultures: Register by August 31 and save $300

What: Creating Competitive Cultures: New Leadership Strategies for Building Great Companies
When: October 27-29, 2010
Where: Denver Marriott City Center, Denver, CO
Event Website: www.competitivecultures.com

Inc., the magazine for growing companies, has partnered with Winning Workplaces to discover and recognize private companies with exemplary workplaces that motivate, engage, and reward employees. Honorees will appear in the June 2010 issue of Inc., and the achievement of these companies will be commemorated at the 2010 Inc. and Winning Workplaces Conference on Creating Competitive Cultures (C3).  At C3, you'll learn about innovative approaches from award-winning companies and extraordinary entrepreneurs, the inspirational tools and processes they deploy to build teams and workplace environments that have a lasting impact on financial results and personal satisfaction.  Creating Competitive Cultures presents the newest leadership strategies for developing the best possible company culture, one that results in a loyal, motivated, inspired, and focused team.

What workplace improvement events, in person or virtual, have you already attended this year?

For a special project we have been doing some additional employee engagement research into one of our 2008 Top Small Workplaces, California-based, leading organic rice farming operation Lundberg Family Farms.

One of the things that stood out to me as part of this effort is how much value, or ROI, the small business gets from its investment in health and wellness initiatives.  Since its business is healthful food, and its employees join its customers in caring about this, it makes sense.  Still, the company goes above and beyond the norm when it comes to wellness – and it can justify its involvement here.

Lundberg employs an on-site Wellness Coordinator who partners with outside agencies to initiate a host of organizational wellness activities including:

1. Sponsoring various charitable, physically challenging contests and company sports teams.
2. Encouraging walking during breaks and throughout the work day.
3. Hiring a trainer to teach all employees proper stretching routines.
4. Providing vending machines onsite so employees can access healthful food and beverages.
5. Offering daily distribution of free fruits and vegetables to its employees.
6. Providing reduced memberships to local fitness centers.
7. Adopting an Injury & Illness Prevention Plan and providing regular trainings and weekly meetings on safety-related topics.
8. Administering free flu shots and blood pressure screenings to all employees.
9. Developing an on-site employee garden to grow vegetables.

The results Lundberg has seen from this truly reflect Winning Workplaces' tagline emphasizing human capital strategies that are "better for people and better for business":

• In 2010, 95% of the workforce underwent a first-time Health Risk Assessment conducted by an outside insurance company.  Participating employees received a discount in their insurance costs. 
• As a result of the health and wellness activities, several employees have reduced their blood pressure, cholesterol and glucose levels.  Many more have made significant lifestyle changes by losing weight, exercising regularly, growing their own vegetables at home and eating healthier meals.
• Both of these employee results keep Lundberg poised for growth through lower turnover/higher average employee tenure, discounted health insurance premiums, and healthier employees who experience less overall stress and are more productive.

Related: Read our Q&A on achieving workplace wellness with stress management therapist Beth Moses.

Image credit: US Scouting Service Project

In a new post on the Small Business CEO blog, What Works for Business blogger Daniel Kehrer shares 13 mistakes that can jinx your business.  The #8 mistake on Kehrer's list is taking good employees for granted.  He explains that,

High turnover and the departure of valued employees can accelerate troubles.  Rewards and recognition - even small gestures - go a long way to keeping your best people around.  Treat new hires with care.  Provide a mentor, if possible.

These are wise words that have been borne out in the case of the small businesses Winning Workplaces has honored over the last 8 years for their ability to realize a substantial payoff of employee engagement and team building activities.  Based on what we've learned from these high-performing organizations, I wrote the following two posts that should help you when it comes to, respectively, recognizing employees effectively, and cost-effectively; and implementing mentoring initiatives that help both the employee and the company:

Employee Recognition on the Cheap

Two Approaches to Mentoring Employees

If you find the information in these links helpful, I invite you to retweet this post on Twitter using the link at the top of this post, or to share it using the button below.  Thanks!

The business justification for employee engagement focused on their continued, on-the-job learning is easy to understand.  It's a win for employees who increase their skills and become more marketable in their careers; and the company wins because their talent has a greater ability to perform at top levels and to innovate, and it's less of a risk and more of an opportunity to promote from within (saving money on recruiting from outside).

Yet, there are myriad options when it comes to educational employee development strategies.  Where should a small business start?  Maybe a more important question is: Considering each investment in this economy needs to generate several times its amount back in returns, what learning initiatives are most effective for small firms?

Luckily, Winning Workplaces has some real-world answers to these questions to share with you to help you decide how to invest when it comes to this important area of human capital strategies.  Our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award application asked applicant companies to give an example of a learning initiative they found to be particularly effective.  Here's how our 20 winners this year responded:

1. A Yard & A Half Landscaping: We spend the equivalent of 1-2 weeks per year offering paid training days for field employees.  Because of the democratic educational setting, by the end of the day, people were helping each other across work crews, and on two occasions, younger employees stepped in to coach crew leaders on machinery that was still unfamiliar to them.
2. All4: For our staff that are in the beginning of their careers and are developing their core consulting and technical skills, we have developed a skills matrix which allows them to know exactly what metrics must be met in order to be promoted to the next position. 
3. Alternative Solutions HomeCare: One interesting program ASH put into place in 2009 was the Dream Manager Program.  Tackling head-on the growing problem of employee disengagement, the program explores the dynamic collaboration that is unleashed when people work together to achieve company objectives and personal dreams.  We had so much positive reaction to this program that we will be continuing it in 2010.
4. Biomark: A couple of years ago we did a several-day team building training.  The effect is that when we employ an idea or theory from this training in our everyday work environment, everyone knows what we are trying to accomplish and is engaged in the process.  This has paid dividends in workplace happiness, turnover, and job performance.
5. Chroma Technology Corp: A few years ago Chroma underwent a full company Lean Manufacturing initiative.  Every employee attended a 2-day workshop and seminar about the fundamentals of Lean Manufacturing.  In addition, 25% of the company was directly involved in two different Lean Mapping and Value Stream courses and projects.  This resulted in $1 million material savings in the first year.
6. Daphne Utilities: We include a large number of our employees in public events involving interaction with our customers.  Here, they work side by side with upper management in events like street festivals and charity fundraisers.  This helps them hear the message being put out from the highest levels, allows top management to get to know each employee a little better, and helps to motivate our workers to take public pride in their work and their company.
7. Dealer.com: We launched uFuel in 2009, a customized online learning management system that was implemented over a 14-month period.  uFuel contains interactive simulations, measures success and knowledge gaps, and creates training programs for areas of improvement.  This learning initiative has been extremely effective at keeping all employees at the leading edge of online marketing best practices and ensuring consistent service for clients.
8. Dixon Schwabl: Our employee development includes an initiative launched by our CEO in 1998 to enhance overall employee communications and allow employees to appreciate each other's differences.  Based on Myers Briggs indicators, it helps frame leadership development, coaching, internal training opportunities, and cross-training.
9. Ginger Bay Salon & Spa: Beginning in 2008 and throughout 2009, we spent significant time with our leadership team opening our books and helping employees understand our financial statements and review our financial performance.  We believe that Open Book Management is likely the main reason that we were able to post results that were not only stronger than our competition, but reflect growth in all areas of our business.
10. MAYA Design: Teaching – many of our employees teach at local universities and we find that allowing this as a paid benefit helps employees learn more about their jobs, how to manage and work with others, and better communication skills.
11. NY Jets: In 2008, the Jets embarked on a first of its kind management development initiative entitled "Take It or Lead It".  Both Business and Football managers partcipated in the sessions.  When this program started, the Jets were in the planning stages of our relocation from Long Island to New Jersey.  HR was able to add in a special section on managing change that prepared mangers for the huge changes employees faced with our relocation.
12. Optimax Systems: The implementation of Job Instruction Training which ensures direction provided from internal trainers is consistent and measurable for effectiveness.  This has allowed us to make sure that people "get it" when instructed on a specific task.
13. Patagonia: Our Employee Development Program temporarily assigns employees to other positions in circumstances where an employee may be out on an extended leave (e.g., maternity leave, an environmental internship, etc.).  Employees participating in this program attain new job skills, have the opportunity to meet more people in the Patagonia community at a new location, and significantly ease the transition back to work for the employee they've replaced.
14. PortionPac Chemical Corp: For 22 years we have held a "Front to Back Day".  Management, office and sales staff spend the day working in the factory.  The "Front" staff gains an appreciation for the skills, talent and physical work that go into making PortionPac, while the factory staff are able to showcase their accomplishments and the attention to detail that goes into making each Pac perfect.  The event fosters communication and suggestions that go back and forth as to how our products can be made better and how the "Front" staff can make life easier for the "Back".
15. Red Door Interactive: We believe that promoting opportunity to change your role at Red Door has prevented talented employees from leaving the company to pursue interests and additional responsibility elsewhere.  Emergent practice areas such as social media and search marketing now comprise over 30% of our total service revenue, and those practice areas are led by people who identified new opportunities and invested in becoming experts by playing to their strengths.
16. Return Path: Most recently our CEO developed and delivered an "Effective Presentations" course.  Content is broken down into small, easily absorbed chunks and reinforced to create a solid foundation that is common for all new hires.  This builds not only a shared vocabulary in our unique business, it builds a shared context.
17. Tarlton Corporation: Our most innovative training program is called Increasing Human Effectives (IHE).  The philosophy behind this training is to help our employees grow personally through this process, which will allow growth professionally.  If they believe in themselves, anything is possible!  Happy employees are productive employees.
18. Tasty Catering: We have 11 advisors/consultants that work with our teams.  Advisors are in the following areas: Banker, Financial, CPA, HR, PR, Marketing, Legal (one for the company and one for the shareholders), IT, Culinary, Dietician and Sales.  The staff benefits by receiving advice from a recognized expert in the field who has larger and smaller clients.
19. The Sky Factory: To further our understanding and experience of the creative process as it applies to our daily work and to the building of the company, we prepared an all-company course with an art historian.  After viewing hundreds of art images and engaging in extensive dialogue it became evident that the process of building a company can (and should) be the same as that of creating a beautiful and lasting work of art.  This notion became practical when a designer aptly observed the skill of a production worker's multiple LED solders.  The fine quality of his work was especially significant because of a recent multi-million dollar fire caused by sloppy work from a competitor's LED system.
20. Van Meter Industrial: One effective learning initiative in our organization is our Foundations training program.  New employees attend this day-and-a-half course near their 90-day milestone anniversary with our company.  Feedback from employees has shown this is fun, interactive, and important training that provides a true insight to our culture, gives the basis for understanding what is important to our company, and sets the tone for who we are and what we represent.

Related: Dive even further into learning activities that will benefit your workplace culture, and your bottom line, by reading our Success Story on ShoreBank.

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons

As Inc. Magazine's profile on our 2010 Top Small Company Workplace award winner PortionPac Chemical Corp got a lot of attention in terms of showing the payoff of employee engagement at a manufacturer – an industry that has been especially hard hit in this economy, and which is not typically known for great workplace practices – today I wanted to share a bit more about another manufacturer: NewAge Industries, one of our 2010 award finalists.

Specifically, I wanted to enlighten you on five practices that leadership of this Pennsylvania-based provider of disposable pharmaceutical processing systems uses to increase competitive advantage.  For 56-year-old NewAge, one solidly quantitative way to define "competitive advantage" is their share price increasing 219% since 2005, while those of their two biggest, publicly traded competitors dropped substantially over the same period.  In addition, the company has never carried debt.

Here are five of NewAge's staff engagement activities that stand out for their revenue-generating and employee retention potential – again, particularly with respect to what other manufacturers are doing right now:

1. Bring on temporary producton employees for up to three months before hiring decisions are made.  This helps NewAge determine if someone is the best cultural fit for the organization, especially when viewed through the lens of employee leadership development potential.
2. Use tough times like these to launch an educational initiative aimed at helping employees understand and address their personal finance concerns.  At NewAge, the CEO in coordination with the accounting department recently hosted five, one-hour sessions with all staff on this.  As a result, many workers have closed the gaps in their personal finances.  This ultimately benefits the company because less financially stressed employees are more productive.
3. Weave cross-training firmly into employee practices and the workplace culture.  Leadership's goal here is to avoid over-hiring in busy times and rampant layoffs in slow times.  They fundamentally believe that this cycle that's so typical of companies is flawed, and they have the numbers to show that their steadier approach works (2009 was their sixth record-breaking year in a row for profits).
4. Pay workers for referrals.  NewAge employees receive a $1,000 bonus for any successful referrals they make.  Management has found that this practice helps to reduce hiring costs and results in higher quality applicants, since employees value the work culture and don't want to be responsible for spoiling it.
5. Put a twist on your tuition reimbursement program and subsidize both work- and non-work-related learning.  NewAge reimburses each employee up to $2,500 annually, and the tuition can be used for any type of learning, whether or not it is directly related to one's job.  Leaders' rationale is that the act of learning anything new and different can spark innovation – not to mention foster employee loyalty.

What people practices, in addition to those mentioned above, do you think directly impact and boost competitive advantage?

Trust building activities may register high on the radar screens of the organizations Winning Workplaces named as 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces in the latest issue of Inc. Magazine, but on the whole among the roughly 27 million small businesses across the U.S., they do not.  These and other human capital strategies are considered by many leaders to be "soft," and therefore, in a down economy, not worth leadership's time and energy compared with other areas of the business.

But as Greg Harris noted on The Science of Work blog yesterday, and as I subsequently tweeted about, Harvard Business Review – long a barometer on where business is and where it's headed – has seemed to focus of late even more on the "fundamentals" of people management.  This means employee engagement strategies to build a more productive workplace culture.

Harris mentioned the May HBR headline "How to Keep Your Star Talent."  Is it a coincidence that this month the AP reported on employment data which show that more employees are jumping ship as the economy improves?

I think not.  Yes, we always see the cycle that in tough economic times, employers don't have to worry as much about retention because people are thankful to have a job, and that in better times they need to pay more attention to it because workers sense a job-seeking advantage and are more apt to leave.  But we are coming out of the Worst Recession Since the Great Depression® – a time when many employers' first reaction was to let go of staff and ask for a great deal of concessions from their remaining workforces.

It's no wonder, then, that employees, feeling beaten down in many cases, are looking for the exits.  This is especially true of top performers, who have a good understanding from their latest performance reviews that they're a strong commodity.

What can keep these folks from leaving?  At a base level, a work environment of trust, respect, and fairness – qualities we point to as one of six building blocks of a winning workplace.

It will be interesting to see how many more leaders and managers put activities designed to maximize trust, such as investment in employee leadership development, at the top of their to-do lists.  And by doing so, moving people practices from the "soft measures" to the "hard measures" column to maintain their competitive advantage.

Your thoughts?

Some of the most (and most vociferous) comments I've seen related to the announcement of our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces last week in the June issue of Inc. Magazine – firms whose human capital strategies contribute to their revenue growth and profitability – appear in response to this post by Manish Mehta on The Jets Stream blog, on NYDailyNews.com.

There are 87 comments to Mehta's post on the NY Jets as of this writing.  Here's what Bob from garfield had to say:

Evidently, no one at Inc. is a Jet season ticket holder.  If Inc. really wants to see how the Jets PSL sales staff do their job, they should view the movie “THE BOILER ROOM”

I've seen that movie and the Jets' sales environment is about as far from what's depicated in it as can be.  For one thing, the salesmen (I don't recall seeing any women in the workplace in the film) were given zero autonomy in their work.  In contrast, here's how the Jets answered the question in our award application, How does the organization encourage employees to participate in important business decisions?

The Jets culture, which is very employee centric and collaborative, enables the senior management of football and business to encourage all employees to share ideas and contribute even in important business decisions.  There are number of ways that we foster this participation.  The most important way is actually in the design of our new facility.  Before we moved to NJ, we had two offices in NYC and Long Island.  The distance between the offices made communication and collaboration challenging.  In the layout of our new building, open workspaces and open door policies reign supreme. The results have been phenomenal.  Managers and employees from different departments can work in small or large groups to develop creative ideas and solutions to important business issues.  A great example of an idea generated from this workspace collaboration is the "Opportunity Knocks" sales campaign for our season tickets and seat licenses.  With such a well known brand, the Jets needed to let the public know of the rare opportunity available to buy season tickets in our new stadium.  Opportunity Knocks was the result.  In the football world, our General Manager encourages his staff from pro personnel assistants to the Assistant General Manager to be actively involved in player decisions.  The scouts, as they are called, study players from college and other professional teams to develop suggestions and recommendations on who should be drafted on Draft Day or who should be signed as a free agent.  There have been many times that an employee will feel passionately about a player that they feel is worthy of the Jets uniform and the decision will be made to go after that player even if the GM is lukewarm on that particular player.  On both sides of our business and both sides of the ball, we would not be able to be as successful a football team if the employees were not encouraged to voice their opinions, share their creative ideas or be enabled to think "outside the box".

Further down in the comments to Mehta's post, greenjohnny wrote:

Sounds nice, should look good on a belt buckle but who really cares.  It's [sic] pretty good that they can make all their employees take two weeks off without pay and still get an award for best place to work for.

This relates to the Jets' answer to another, topical question in our application, Over the last year, what kind of impact has the economy had on your business? Please briefly explain how your company has responded?  Here's how the NFL franchise responded:

Football is not immune from the economic downturn and recession that has gripped the entire country.  Our local revenue comes primarily from ticket sales and sponsorships.  Our fans (customers) have been affected by layoffs, salary freezes and reductions in work hours.  Our sponsors have seen a dramatic decrease in budgets for spending on advertising.  Consequently, the Jets have been affected by a slowdown in revenue generated by ticket sales and sponsorship deals.  Over the course of 2009, we were challenged to find ways to decrease spending and cut costs.  Since our employees are the key to our success, this exercise needed to be done with layoffs as an extreme last measure.  Many teams around the NFL in the early part of 2009 were laying off their employees to save money.  ...  We froze salaries for the year.  Since we still needed to find extra savings, we made a crucial decision to furlough business employees for 2 weeks versus eliminating positions.  The furloughs were scheduled for the slowest time in our year at the end of June and beginning of July.  Employees had to choose 2 out of 4 weeks to take their furlough.  The response from employees was positive.  They were extremely grateful that they didn't have to say goodbye to a friend.  Our senior management participated as well, which made the program very credible.  It was tough for our employees to lose 2 weeks of pay, but overall the furlough program worked successfully.

In short, the Jets took a page from several of our previous honorees faced with tough decisions and chose to share the pain rather than lay anyone off.  The fact that senior leadership participated speaks volumes and, as you can see, helped maintain their productive workplace culture of ownership and high employee engagement.

I should mention that as part of our employee engagement research for our award, we conducted interviews with staff from different levels within the Jets' organization, and everything they told us about their employee practices, including what's excerpted above, checks out.  Especially for their industry, they are truly a Winning Workplace.

Related: For more on the Jets' new workplace environment, including some great pictures, check out this feature from the June Inc. Magazine.

Photo credit: Nikolas Koenig/Inc.

At Winning Workplaces, we sometimes hear from business leaders that while they acknowledge that happier employees are more productive – and that, in turn, affects revenue and profitability – it can be difficult to tie team building strategies such as special employee awards or allowing workers to bring their dogs to work directly to the balance sheet.

It can be hard to pinpoint the payoff of employee engagement.  Even when leaders work off the feedback of a well-executed employee opinion survey to implement more or better engagement activities, getting bottom line returns to match or exceed estimates is not a science.  This is further complicated by down economies like the one we're in now, as well as the fact that almost no employee practice solutions produce overnight returns.

So I appreciated Dr. Anna Erickson's reframing of this issue in her post yesterday on the Good Company Blog.  She asks, "Are Employers Facing a Deficit of Trust?"  This implies that a workplace culture of trust, respect, and fairness is a form of currency.  It also implies that a deficit of this currency is bad for the bottom line, while a surplus of it strengthens the bottom line.

In fact, the data we gather as part of our Top Small Company Workplaces competition verifies this line of thinking.  The 40 winners and finalist organizations for our award this year have better overall trust building activities in place, and as a result they had higher 2009 revenue than the other 457 applicants (average of $42 million vs. $27 million).  In addition, as I explained in this post, a greater share of the winners and finalists were profitable in 2009, and they have longer average employee tenures and lower turnover.

The short of this is that, to the extent you can implement or strengthen staff engagement practices designed to build greater trust in your workforce, the better it will be for your balance sheet in the long run.

Related: This recent post cites evidence from John Jantsch's new book which finds that stronger cultures also tend to increase referrals – a major source of revenue for most businesses.

For months I've been sharing employee engagement research trends of Winning Workplaces' 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award finalists – the 40 organizations out of nearly 500 that applied for our award this year.  Many of those blog posts ended with a reminder to look for the June issue of Inc., which would feature the winners of our award.

Well, now the issue is out, as is our press release on the 2010 winners!  Actually, most if not all subscribers already have the issue in their hands; it will be available on newsstands starting tomorrow, June 8.

So now that news of the winners is out, I'm excited to provide more value for you here, in the form of both trends when it comes to the payoff of employee engagement that the winners see, and – perhaps even better for your company – specific best practices that you can learn from and adapt to help grow your business.

In that vein, below are ROI metrics for each of the 20 winners.  Click on a company name for more information about the firm on our website.

• A Yard & a Half (landscaper, Waltham, MA): employee development strategies helped reduce the company's indirect expenses.
• All4, Inc. (air quality consultancy, Kimberton, PA): training and a flat organizational structure have helped the company grow its market share in a down economy.
• Alternate Solutions HomeCare (home health care services for the elderly, Kettering, OH): A focus on creating highly individual employee development plans has helped ASH consistently score higher than the average EBITDA of four of the largest publicly owned home healthcare agencies in the country.
• Biomark, Inc. (electronic ID technology supplier, Boise, ID): Funding growth using internal methods while keeping debt to a minimum has helped Biomark grow while their competitors are shrinking.
• Chroma Technology Corp. (precision optical filter manufacturer, Bellows Falls, VT): The company's focus on customer service and creating outperforming products has helped it grow revenues in a tough economy.
• Daphne Utilities (water and natural gas service provider to the City of Daphne, AL): A pay for performance system, cross training, and coaching have had a triple bottom line impact on the company.
• Dealer.com (online marketing solutions provider for the automotive industry, Burlington, VT): Employee practices such as job rotaton and internal mentoring have increased customer satisfaction, and have also led to awards like Deloitte's Technology Fast 500, which have aided recruiting.
• Dixon Schwabl (Advertising and PR services, Victor, NY): A focus on identifying new hires that will best fit their workplace culture and a strategic talent management program has helped the company to earn a profit in a challenging economy.
• Ginger Bay Salon & Spa (salon and day spa, Kirkwood, MO): Leadership's reliance on employees to revise its service offerings based on declining customer visits helped the firm realize continued revenue growth, and with no layoffs.
• MAYA Design, Inc. (design consultancy, Pittsburgh, PA): Innovative benefits including funding viable, employee-created, complimentary companies has kept productivity high and turnover low.
• NY Jets (NFL member franchise, Florham Park, NJ): Strong benefits and a skills-training program for both business and football managers has increased performance on the fan side (four playoff appearances in 10 years) as well as advertising, merchandising, and other sales.
• Optimax Systems, Inc. (prototype optics manufacturer, Ontario, NY): A strong focus on continuous improvement and other workforce investments helped Optimax to achieve its higest number of bookings ever in 2009.
• Patagonia (technical outdoor clothing and travel gear designer/distributor, Ventura, CA): Though the economy worsened and competition increased in 2009, Patagonia grew revenue thanks partly to people practices including job shadowing, promoting from within, and open-book management.
• PortionPac Chemical Corp (industrial packager/marketer of environmentally sustainable liquid cleaning detergents, Chicago, IL): Practices including executives working on the factory floor and giving workers autonomy helped the company to grow revenue and keep all staff in 2009, while competitors suffered losses and shed jobs.
• Red Door Interactive (Internet/e-business strategy solutions provider, San Diego, CA): An investment in employee development geared toward learning new competencies and practices in emerging technologies helped the firm win related business representing a third of their revenue in 2009.
• Return Path, Inc. (spam-avoidance solutions provider for email senders, New York, NY): Practices including an extensive on-boarding program and learning and team building activities in the workplace have helped Return Path achieve a 70% market share in their sector.
• Tarlton Corp (general contractor and construction management, St. Louis, MO): Extensive training and open-book management helped Tarlton to finish 2009 with a Safety Total Incident Rate below the industry average.
• Tasty Catering (Corporate catering solutions provider, Elk Grove Village, IL): A focus on promoting from within and communicating business performance and activities via weekly, bilingual newsletters were factors in Tasty Catering earning revenues above the industry average in 2009.
• The Sky Factory (factory-direct product manufacturer/distributor, Fairfield, IA): Team building strategies including, most notably, involving all employees in all major decisions contributed to revenue growth in 2008 and 2009, when domestic markets experienced major declines in new construction.
• Van Meter Industrial (wholesale products distributor, Cedar Rapids, IA): Practices such as a program that encourages staff to make small changes in work habits to improve processes as well as incentives including performance bonuses have helped the company consistently rank in the upper quartile performance of financial measurements.

You can learn more about how to build a profitable and productive workplace at the Creating Competitive Cultures (C3) conference that Inc. Magazine is hosting in Denver in October.  Go here for more info on this event.

Regarding the oil spill off the Gulf Coast, we know the following:

• Even with 92,000 employees, BP, the company most responsible for the spill out of several that were vested in the rig that exploded on April 20, has not been able to stop the flow of oil from the damaged well.
• While the federal government has considerable manpower and resources to assist BP in stopping the flow, they must defer to BP as subject matter expert in this crisis (mostly to their engineering team).
• It is urgent that the flow of oil be stopped to save the environment and companies and jobs in the region that depend on a clean ocean, and, from a profit motive perspective, to not lose more of a precious commodity.

We also know that small businesses are the most prevalent employers, representing over 99% of all firms.  Thus, it seems natural to ask if stopping the spill is one, massive opportunity for small businesses to "do well as they do good."

I asked this question this week on LinkedIn.  I've received three answers so far, with five days left for folks to weigh in.  I invite you to add your thoughts.

Related: Here's one answer to the question: Opflex's absorbent foam, which BP has agreed to purchase to help in its cleanup efforts.  I wonder how workplace team building and employee engagement activities are helping Opflex meet demand right now!

Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons

Last week I wrote on employee engagement around group decision making.  Working off an article by the Wharton School, I surmised that as a company grows, its ability to reap returns from making all major company decisions by consensus worsens.  In other words, I asked, Is size the enemy of consensus decision making?

I was pleasantly surprised to see that Bill Witherspoon, CEO of The Sky Factory – an Iowa-based factory-direct product manufacturer and distributor that's one of 40 finalist organizations for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplace award – left a comment.  I thought it was so insightful that it deserved its own post.  Here's part of Witherspoon's response to the question I posed:

The barrier to consensus is not group size or number of participants.  The barrier lies in:

1. Different levels of information among individuals within the operation (the result of transparency or lack thereof).
2. Different "political" agendas within the operation (the result of hierarchical management systems).
3. Lack of uniformly understood goals of the operation.
4. Lack of history - meaning the longer consensus decision making is practiced, the more efficient it gets as the group becomes familiar with the process and develops a deep understanding of the entire operation to which decisions apply.

I can't deny that Witherspoon's relentless focus on building and relying on consensus decision making – including getting rid of the barriers he mentions above – has produced incredible results for his business: Only 8 years old, The Sky Factory grew revenues in 2008 and 2009, both of which were devastating years for their marketplace peers.

Related: Witherspoon mentioned in his comment that the company posts their workplace culture values on their website.  Here's the link to that page and their five "cultural principals."  I think they're a fantastic foundation for team engagement activities, whether or not a company leads by consensus.

Photo credit: KRUU 100.1 FM

Will this week go down as a low point for performance reviews?  Since The New York Times asked on one of its blogs on Monday if it's "Time to Review Workplace Reviews," workplace researchers and business leaders alike have jumped on the bandwagon of questioning their effectiveness, and even their place among other, common employee development strategies.

The main criticisms of performance reviews, as Palo Alto Software Founder and President Tim Berry echoes from the NYT article on Small Business Trends, are that:

• They add signficantly to employee stress, and
• They can be so subjective in some cases as to render them meaningless.

Winning Workplaces' own employee engagement research shows that, at least in small businesses (which is to say, most businesses), performance reviews are not only an integral part of the people practices strategy, but they're delivering results.  The term "performance review" showed up 71 times in the 497 company applications we received for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award competition; 9 out of 10 of these firms are profitable, they've managed to stay in business for an average of 16 years, and they save on recruiting costs by filling 1 out of 5 of open positions from within (contributing to respectable average employee tenure of 4 years) (source).

So in playing devil's advocate and working under the assumption that performance reviews are a worthwhile investment for an organization, here are 10 ways to make them meaningful, for employees and especially for the company.  These tactics are drawn from reporting on our award-winning firms on our website, presentations leaders of some of these firms have given at our past annual conferences, and other posts on this blog.

1. A goal of the review should be to build a relationship between managers and subordinates.
2. SMART goals – especially the Measurable and Attainable attributes – help make managers' feedback more objective and less subjective.
3. If employees' expectations of a raise following a review are causing stress, separate the pay element from the review.  If you plan for and communicate regular, periodic (normally once a year) salary adjustments, the persistent question of "When will I get a raise?" will disappear.
4. The more closely an individual's goals can be connected to an organization's performance goals, the more significant they become to the employee.
5. Too many companies fall into the habit of having reviews be the main one-on-one, in-depth dialogue between managers and subordinates.  Ideally, managers should be having far more frequent conversations with subordinates that address progress toward key goals.  This makes the feedback in a review setting much more palatable and less surprising for the employee.
6. Along the lines of "no surprises" for the employee as mentioned above, if you do tie reviews to compensation and/or bonuses, using open-book management – in which employees see the company's financial statements and, in many cases, are trained to know what the numbers mean – delivers value come review time, insofar as employees will have a much better idea whether a pay increase or bonus is fair; and also why they're not getting one, if that's the case depending on company performance.
7. Put employees in the driver's seat: empower and train managers to task employees with setting their own individual goals at the end of a performance review, when planning ahead for the next one.  While the goals employees present to managers will probably not be good to go straight away, even if they're adjusted, the sense of self-empowerment employees feel from being actively involved in their role will not diminish, and in fact it can make them more committed and productive.
8. An alternative to the above tip that's also proven to work well is to use a mix of individual, deparment, and overall organizational goals.  At Illinois-based ShoreBank their "magic ratio" for this is 70%/20%/10%.
9. Another approach is to move from individual reviews to group-based reviews.  Our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award finalist Cargas Systems, based in Pennsylvania, does monthly "stop light" reviews, allowing groups to gauge areas in need of improvement and provide an outlet for all to share opinions and stay involved.  This can be particularly effective when combined with tip #3 above.
10. If your company core values emphasize the greater community in some way, try incorporating the related value(s) in a goal in your reviews.  You may find the extra productivity that comes with an employee seeing his employer as caring about him as a whole person, and not just as a business asset, produces more revenue than a more traditional, numbers-based goal.

How do you approach performance reviews as a means to create a more productive workplace culture?

Photo credit: Chief Happiness Officer blog