Last week I enjoyed a week off with my family in Canada, specifically Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island.  But before I had even left the states, I was reminded of an important lesson when it comes to hiring for fit as well as employee engagement and workplace team building.

My wife and I flew from LAX to Newark Liberty International Airport before connecting on a flight from there to Halifax.  Between our arrival and second departure gate was a small, '50s-style diner.  Not having much time and knowing there'd be at least a snack on our second-leg flight, we sat down there to split a plate of fries.  We wanted to keep ourselves hydrated, so we each opted for free glasses of water instead of sodas (you'll see why this is important in a second).

When we arrived the place was maybe a third full – not too busy for the one waiter to serve us, as I can say with authority from my high school days as a waiter.  Yet it was immediately apparent that he preferred to favor tables with more people who were ordering more items.  That's understandable because, in theory, that's where the bigger tips were.

What he shouldn't have assumed, though, is that we would leave a proportionally smaller tip.  It so happened that we had bills and no change so, proportionally, had he done an even passable job, he would have gotten a very nice tip for his time involved.  But he initially ignored us, literally rolled his eyes when we asked for a plate of fries and two waters, didn't check on us once he delivered our order, and, worst of all when it comes to waiting etiquette, took our check and tip before we had left!

On our way out, when my wife shared that his tip could have been a lot higher if he had treated us better, the waiter said lazily, "Well, you only ordered fries."  Since when does amount spent dictate the service level received!?  (This is an equation that doesn't factor into the business models of our Top Small Company Workplaces, BTW.)

If you run a company, especially in the hospitality industry, you might be thinking that this experience reflects more on the individual employee and doesn't impact the business as much.  Not necessarily; on our return visit to the same airport en route from Halifax to Los Angeles, we noticed the same waiter in the same restaurant – steering clear of both and getting our food on elsewhere in the terminal.  A different customer-employee experience could have meant repeat business for that diner.

The takeaway?  When you have a more or less stable, captive audience such as in an airport or mall, people practices including hiring for fit and using employee development strategies to deliver excellent service can make a huge difference on your bottom line.

Related: In this webinar recording on our website, two of our award-winning small business CEOs share proven tips for creating a fantastic customer service culture.

Photo credit: Maurice Prather

Given this blog's focus on how employee retention tips and other people practices lead to a more productive workplace culture – and how leadership strategies such as succession planning reduce dependency of the business on key people if they leave or are otherwise taken out of the equation – a reader might conclude that decisions made in the C-suite matter less now than they once did.

This conclusion would be wrong, however, argues Tyler Leverty, assistant professor of finance in the University of Iowa's Tippie College of Business.  According to this Newswise article, which references Leverty's paper "Dupes or Incompetents: An Examination of Management’s Impact on Firm Distress," some CEOs significantly improve a firm’s performance, while others hurt it.

Writes Newswise,

[Leverty] found ... good CEOs can remove their firms from regulatory scrutiny 8 to 16 percent faster than a poor manager.  And in insurance companies that are going out of business, a more talented CEO can get a better return on the firm’s assets by up to 10 cents on the dollar.

The takeaway is that events and other learning opportunities that deliver a good ROI for leaders are worth the investment – even in tough times.  This is why Winning Workplaces is excited to partner with Inc. Magazine to host the Creating Competitive Cultures (C3) Conference in Denver on October 27-29, 2010.  As Inc. says on their C3 website, CEOs and other attendees can expect to learn "the newest leadership strategies for developing the best possible company culture, one that results in a loyal, motivated, inspired, and focused team."

Click here to learn more about this event.  You'll want to register by tomorrow, August 31, to get the early bird rate, a $300 savings.

Since I wrote this "line in the sand" post back in March arguing that you should abandon a strategy of hiring for skills in favor of hiring instead for attitude and fit (for a more harmonious and productive workplace culture), I've written several more citing outside sources – as opposed to our own employee engagement research – that help make this case.

But perhaps Brett Owens, CEO of software startup Chrometa, makes the most compelling case for getting the "right people on the bus" in the first place; his post on the Small Business CEO blog pits this as a choice for leaders as opposed to using effective employee leadership development strategies to get the most from the people already on your team.

Creating a hypothetical example from his own experience, Owens says the "coached up" productivity gains of current staff members might make them, at most, 50% more productive than a baseline performer.  Yet, a new hire who's a better workplace fit might be three times – 300% – more productive than the baseline employee.  Thus, he concludes that getting the best from your current staff is

important - but when we do the math, we small business owners know it’s not nearly as important as getting the very best people in the first place.

Related: Leaders, do you have any bad workplace experiences that have resulted from not hiring the right people?  Share them, and your solutions to this issue for the benefit of your fellow readers, here.

Could the current worker strike of the Mott's plant in Williamson, New York – as expertly covered last week by The New York Times – be to the workforce and the economy what the Google-Verizon deal is to advocates of Net Neutrality?  (That is, a sign of bad things to come?)

Check out this excerpt of the NYT article on the Mott's strike, which began almost three months ago:

The strike has become so important because of the prominence of the brands and because of its unusual nature: a highly profitable company is taking the rare and bold step of demanding large-scale concessions.

...

The workers ... are incensed that the company is demanding givebacks when it posted record profits last year and increased its dividend by 67 percent in May.

This represents what I'm seeing as a trend: companies – typically, large public corporations – holding onto profits after already making moderate to significant workforce cuts, as opposed to following their pattern in past economic recoveries and reinvesting the returns back into the business in the form of employee development strategies (including benefits).

However, if this plays out on a larger scale (other large companies taking a cue from Mott's if they're successful, regardless of whether there's union involvement), it could potentially lead to a deflationary outcome if workers' wages slowly spiral downward.  If that happens, companies could join workers in a lose-lose situation, because that would mean even less disposable income from most Americans to spend on their products and services.

Winning Workplaces takes the position that for the long-term good of companies and individuals, midsize and larger companies (especially) should change their workforce investment strategy from one of further cuts to one of sustained, smart investment.  Using employee engagement best practices, they can benefit quickly and over the long haul from the increased productivity, lower turnover, etc., that come from treating workers fairly, and not unnecessarily harshly, when it comes to what to do with their profits after bouncing back from the worst of this recession.

Related: Read this post which argues, based on business school research, that a consequence of deep workforce cuts is long-term industry lag.

The following is a guest post by Sean Conrad.  Sean is a Senior Product Analyst at Halogen Software, one of the leading providers of performance appraisal software.

Most of us are familiar with Gallup's employee engagement research and the twelve statements they use to measure it.

When I look at the list, it strikes me that there are some basic employee performance management practices that, if done well, address most of these needs.  They include:

• Giving employees meaningful feedback on a regular basis.
• Being clear about goals and helping employees see how their work matters to the organization.
• Recognizing and rewarding employees fairly.
• Giving employees opportunities for growth and development.

Given their importance and impact, we'd do well as managers to give them our time and attention.

Give Employees Meaningful Feedback on an Ongoing Basis

Research consistently tells that employees want meaningful, ongoing feedback.  But many of us struggle to make it part of our work culture.  Here are some things that can help:

Increase the frequency of your performance appraisals
Instead of just doing annual performance appraisals, conduct quarterly mini reviews.  This helps to give managers and employees a regularly committed interval for dialogue and feedback.
 
Gather feedback from others
Feedback from multiple sources is broader and more objective, and helps the manager and employee get a more accurate view of their performance.  You can keep it simple, and just request feedback from another employee or manager who works with the employee, or conduct more formal 360 degree assessments.

Keep ongoing notes on performance
Keeping and sharing notes on performance year-round helps to better document performance, opens up the dialogue between a manager and an employee, and makes writing performance appraisal faster and easier.  Highlights, challenges and disconnects that might not otherwise be discovered until the annual performance appraisal meeting can be shared and explored in a timely way.
 
Define Clear Goals and Link Them to Organizational Goals

Employees need to clearly know what is expected of them, and understand how their work contributes to the organization's mission and success.

SMART goals are broadly recognized as the most effective way to write clear goals.  Specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and time-bound goals let employees know what is expected of them, how success will be measured, and when they must complete work.

But we should also give employees a context for their work by linking their goals to higher-level organizational goals, so they understand how they're contributing to organizational goals.

Recognize and Reward Your Employees Fairly and Consistently

Recognition and rewards should be frequent and come in many forms.  Since we're all motivated by different things, it's important to know what your employees value, so you can reward them effectively.  But all programs should be tied to employee performance. And your employees should know the metrics used as measurement.

Provide Opportunities for Growth and Development

Employees need to feel as though they have a future with an organization, and a career path that helps them further develop their knowledge, skills and abilities.  Make sure you provide things like formal training, challenging work assignments, mentoring programs, etc.

Related: For more guidance on creating an effective performance management system as part of a winning set of team building and employee development strategies, check out our Ask An Expert column on measuring key competencies.

On August 4 I told you about our new feature for email subscribers, a weekly people practices email geared toward improving your company's bottom line.  Tom Walter, CEO of our 2010 Top Small Company Workplace Tasty Catering, commented on that post saying it's a great idea.

This week he shared specifics with me on exactly why he thinks business leaders should sign up for this free email (emphasis mine):

The Weekly Bottom Line-Improving People Practice email should benefit all business leaders.  The world has become commoditized.  The true marketplace differentiator is human capital.  I enjoy learning the Best Practices other companies use with their most valuable asset - their people.

An engaged workforce is typically harmonious, productive and profitable.  These Best Practices eliminate the need to manage.  We have replaced management with effective leaders armed with Best Practices, and the difference has been remarkable.

While Winning Workplaces surely plays only a small part in Tasty Catering's success, you can't argue that they're not doing a lot of things right in their staff engagement that comprises their highly productive workplace culture: As we shared in the company's award profile, in a very tough year broadly and certainly in their industry (2009), their employee leadership development and other strategies helped them earn above-average revenues.

Register now to start getting our weekly, bottom line-improving people practices email FREE in your inbox.

What an amazing community of small business leaders Winning Workplaces is fortunate to know!  After I wrote this post last week providing resources to help leaders set their new managers up for success – in which I shared a facet of our honoree Andrew Field's approach to this – the President of PrintingForLess.com emailed me with expanded tactics intended to help you with your own employee leadership development of this pivotal group of workers.

According to Field, here are some things that PFL implemented to grow great first-time managers in a relatively short time:

The critical first step in cultivating new managers is to identify candidates before they are needed in their new positions, and to begin giving them the preparation they need well in advance.  It is critical to have an explicit "leadership pipeline" and to hold yourself and your management team accountable for the development of your future leaders.

At PFL, this looks like having a standing agenda item at our broad monthly management team meeting that involves each person who has direct reports identifying their top and bottom performers, along with what they are doing to grow/reward/engage their top people, and what they are doing to "coach up" their low performers.

The second tool for success that we equip our new managers with is a template for regular (weekly or biweekly) one-on-one conversations with each of their direct reports.  The critical elements are personal connections, specific project updates, and discussion about professional growth plans.

Many entrepreneurs say that they don't need regular, scheduled one-on-ones because they have so much impromptu contact with their teams.  Nice try.

Spur-of-the-moment discussions are important, but they are not a substitute for regular one-on-ones, which encompass deep discussions focused mostly around the employee's work and development plans, rather than just current action items.

Our third support system for new leaders is that we provide them with development paths that include opportunities to expand their experience levels within the company.  In addition to education and mentorship (both of which are structured), we give future and current leaders the opportunity to test themselves in leadership roles, ranging from running a small project to leading a large group of people.  We move them around to different areas of the company in order to broaden their knowledge base, as well as giving them a chance to build robust networks within the organization.  Critical to the success of this OJT ("On the Job Training") is that we structure discussions about learnings and challenges.  We have found that peer-to-peer discussions are every bit as productive as boss-to-employee interactions.

At the end of the day, PFL has grown our best people by identifying potential leaders, modeling good leadership habits, and showering them with resources aimed at nurturing their growth.

Related: Andrew Field clearly knows his stuff when it comes to team building in the workplace – and seeing a payoff of employee engagement.  Learn even more about his employee development strategies on our website.

This new post on the Business Pundit blog caught my attention: Citing data from Wall St. Cheat Sheet, it contains a map of the U.S. showing the scope of business closures in FY 2009.  The number of closures are given for states suffering from the highest number of them, including New York, California, Texas, Georgia, and Florida.

This is across-the-board data, representing all businesses, large and small.  But what about just small businesses?  And more specifically, as a point of discussion relative to the findings from Wall St. Cheat Sheet, how many of them are expanding or planning to expand in this environment?

Our employee engagement research from our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award sheds some light here.  We asked our 497 applicant firms about their future organizational goals; 101 of them, or 20.3%, used terms describing expansion in the immediate future including "new location," "new office," and "new facility."

I thought it would be illuminating to juxtapose the map of U.S. business closures from Wall St. Cheat Sheet with a map I created showing the breakdown of our 101 small business award applicants expanding or looking to expand soon:

Click on our map in blue to view a larger version.

Besides company size – our applicants have no more than 750 employees – what else is different in the survey samples comprising these two maps?  We know that our award applicants understand the payoff of employee engagement and team building on their bottom line, and accordingly develop people practices to leverage this.  This enhances their ability to invest in the business, including expansion – even in a tough economy.

Can we say that about the much larger company sample in Wall St. Cheat Sheet's research?  Not necessarily.

What's your reaction to these two maps?

On her blog last week, Harvard Business School's Rosabeth Moss Kanter identified setting clear expectations about everything as one of four things groups want that leaders can't provide.  She writes,

No matter how much leaders try to define expectations, lay out the nature of likely events, or describe the steps that the group will be going through, it's not enough.

My question is, while it may not be enough to fully satisfy groups of employees for ideal workforce effectiveness – is it enough to move the business forward in a meaningful way (even if that means not sliding backward in a recession)?

The workplace team building and employee engagement experiences of 8 small businesses that applied for our Top Small Company Workplaces award this year – including 2 winners – show that building clear employee expectations from leaders into the strategy contributes to organizational success.  Consider that the companies I'll tell you a bit more about below:

• Have been in business an average of 13 years,
• Grew revenue more than $5 million on average from 2008 to 2009,
• Went from 50% being profitable in 2008 to 75% being profitable in 2009, and
• Decreased average turnover by close to 3% from 2008 to 2009.

Specifically, here's who the firms are and how they maintain their success, in part, by being intentional about setting clear expectations:

Awarepoint - Real-time awareness technologies to monitor equipment and people - San Diego, CA
"Awarepoint helps managers get the best out of our staff.  The in-depth performance review helps managers and employees have better conversations, set clear expectations and build useful development plans.  This method also helps our leaders learn to identify poor performance so that it can be dealt with quickly, while developing the solid performers and building the business."

Enhanced Recovery Corporation - Financial Services - Jacksonville, FL
"The Owners, VPs, Directors, Department Heads, and Operations Management Team are all committed to the continued success of all ERC employees.  From Peer to Peer feedback to our Open Door Policy, employees of ERC always have clear expectations and development opportunities.  All departments at ERC are committed to ensuring constant development of employees at all levels within the organization."

FMYI - Software - Portland, OR
"We have done a lot more than what's expected of a small company such as providing medical benefits from day one with only a couple of employees even though it wasn't required by Oregon law.  We also want to be more authentic and fully integrated with our sustainability commitment.  We will sustain employee culture through ongoing sustainability discussions (via Northwest Earth Institute courses), clear expectations written into job descriptions and reviews about our doer/helper culture."

NouvEON - Consulting - Charlotte, NC
"NouvEON's Talent Management and People Care Division has several platforms that allow us to set goals, dialogue throughout the year, establish clear expectations, and perform 360 reviews, as well as measure and track potential.  We map Performance AND Potential and communicate to our employees where we see strengths and gaps.  It is through open communication and candid conversation that we help individuals grow in their jobs."

NY Jets (Winner) - Professional football team - Florham Park, NJ
"When our current management development initiative started, the Jets were in the planning stages of our relocation from Long Island to NJ.  HR was able to add in a special section on managing change that prepared mangers for the huge changes employees faced with our relocation.  The training sessions consisted of 6 modules: The Role of the Manager, Setting Clear Expectations, Feedback Skills, Delegation and Motivation, Handling Performance Issues, and Managing Change. The initiative proved to be highly successful for all managers; the learnings from the trainings are still used by the managers today."

Portico Systems Inc. - Software - Blue Bell, PA
"People succeed when they care share their ideas, build their skills, collaborate with others, and move into the realm of confidence that comes with mastery.  The masters become mentors and guide others with wisdom and a desire to enable others with positive reinforcement.  This is the environment that Portico is cultivating as we grow the organization and the people who are working to succeed.  Employees are provided with clear expectations, direction and feedback from supervisors, and opportunities and monetary and non-monetary ways incentives to succeed."

Red Door Interactive (Winner) - Advertising - San Diego, CA
"Our culture has been one of open dialogue, learning and progression since the company was formed eight years ago.  The family and team oriented environment at Red Door Interactive fosters open communication, leadership, clear expectations and teamwork.  A visit to Red Door Interactive will clearly display the open environment since the office is completely devoid of doors; even the CEO. Internal committees encourage feedback and collaboration to maintain our culture and engagement."

Sierra w/o Wires - Computer systems and related services - Pittsburgh, PA
"Regular and real communication is essential to establishing any corporate culture, community and collaboration.  In our organization this type of communication ranges involving employees in the project planning and estimating, to regular team and one-on-one update meetings, and also establishing clear expectations for each employee on what needs to be done, when."

How clear are the expectations in your organization?  Do your people practices help or hinder this?

When it comes to staff engagement activities for a more productive workplace culture, how important are newly promoted managers?

VERY (so important, I put the answer to my question in its own paragraph).

In fact, the CEO of one of the most successful small businesses we've honored for their bottom line-enhancing people practices – Andrew Field of Montana-based PrintingForLess.com – told us a few years ago that he doesn't blink at spending half of his time mentoring and modeling tasks with his new managers.  He sees their success as that important to his business' ability to satisfy existing customers and attract new ones, as well as improve internal processes.

If you're reading this, you likely understand and value this connection.  With that in mind, here are three resources to help you make the most of the new managers in your organization:

1. Dan Rockwell's post on succeeding when you’re new - 8 hints for new supervisors on his Leadership Freak blog
2. Our editorial on the importance of new manager training
3. Wally Bock's guest article for us on 10 steps to improve your bosses' performance

Are there any good books or other resources you have turned to and would recommend to other business leaders?  Please share your picks in the comments.

Last month on TIME magazine's Curious Capitalist blog, Barbara Kiviat, citing the New York Times, argued that because

Hundreds of thousands of Americans have enrolled in federally financed training programs in recent years, only to remain out of work ... job retraining is a wash.

This position may make sense from a policymaker or an economist's point of view – and in fact the Curious Capitalist blog carries a tagline saying it's about the economy and markets as much as it is business.

Yet, based on the evidence we see from the applications for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, small business leaders don't view retraining as a wash.  However, most* do keep tabs on it as a measurement of their failure to attract and retain the best people while aligning those people with the company's needs and deploying effective employee leadership development strategies.

In other words, while they value retraining, they see it as an employee educational investment of last resort.

Consider the responses to our essay question on how people practices contribute to the top line revenue and bottom line profitability from the following three companies:

KeyLogic Systems, Inc., West Virginia:
"At KeyLogic our product IS our people; which we hire through strong recruitment and employee referral programs.  We have a low turnover ratio which has impacted both the top line revenue (allowing for employee to customer continuity) and bottom line profitability by allowing us to focus more on developing our current employee resources through professional training as opposed to the high cost of recruiting, re-training and developing new employees."

Prenova, Georgia:
"Since our managers and executives interact with lower-level employees, they can impart much of their knowledge and information on an as-needed basis, rather than waiting for issues to be discovered (often because of a costly emergency) and spending large amounts of time and labor developing ways to distribute that information. Conversely, employees can quickly and easily access other team members capable of discussing issues, and receive retraining when necessary."

Pro CNC Inc., Washington State:
"Being very thorough in our hiring practices has also led to extremely low turn-over which certainly has an effect on profitability and revenue.  We don't spend a lot of time retraining new hires and can focus on the business of serving our customers."

*I should note that a few firms we've come across – as part of our workplace award as well as our consulting and speaking engagements – don't view retraining as an if-needed effort.  These rare enterprises actively budget for this as part of their staff engagement activities, looking to help those who want to continue working for the company, but in a different area.  They see retraining as a means to hold onto this talent and keep using them to drive results.

Related: Read our review of A Manager's Guide to Coaching, which is aimed at helping organizations decrease their time and money spent on recruiting in addition to retraining.

I don't yet have it in my hands, but I already know I'm going to like the latest book from workplace generational expert Neil Howe, Millennials in the Workplace.

According to StreetInsider.com, Howe "turns [the] downbeat message [from the media on Millennials, aka Generation Y] on its head."  Taking the position that Millennials are an asset and opportunity rather than a lazy (insert other adjectives here) liability, the website writes, Howe's new book serves in part as a resource for employee engagement and team building strategies to find and keep them.

Providing a sample of the employee retention tips Howe shares in Millennials, StreetInsider.com links to this pdf from Howe's company, LifeCourse.  At its core is the following list of recruiting and retention strategies tailored to this young generation that, some reports say, became the most pervasive one of all this year: 

1. Treat them like VIPs
2. Co-recuit the parents
3. Find them early
4. Look after them
5. Offer structure and teach them the basics
6. Provide tight cycles of feedback
7. Don't offer a "McJob"
8. Make them part of the group
9. Be active in the community
10. Take an interest in their success

I really like that the pdf includes a section on "What To Do" under each of the above strategies to take them from the world of the ambiguous to the practical.

Given the Millennial workforce's size and its stature as the dominant generation in the work world for years to come, it's no surprise that our Top Small Company Workplaces are already using many of the above strategies to help them tackle pressing issues from process and supply chain improvement to sales lead cultivation and delivery.

Related: Read my 4 reasons why Millennials may be the ones to pull us out of our troubled economy.

Last July, when Amazon.com was on the verge of acquiring Zappos.com, I questioned if the move would lead to the demise of the unique – and uniquely powerful in terms of buzz and sales – productive workplace culture Tony Hsieh built within his retail business.

A year later, I'm happy to note that just the opposite seems to be true.  Hsieh has remained in place as CEO and, more importantly from an employee engagement perspective, he's become even more visible as a "chief culture officer": I was one of many bloggers and reporters to pick up on his New York Times Q&A in January in which he shared the benefits of attracting and retaining offbeat workers.  Last month, Hsieh went even further in sharing his workplace culture beliefs, practices, and successes with the release of his book Delivering Happiness.

Through it all, Zappos continues to wow customers with its incredible service, helping to maintain sales in a tough economy.  What's more, the company serves as a beacon of hope to job seekers and a vital source of tax revenues in hard hit Las Vegas.

Honest Tea, a finalist for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, appears to be following in Zappos' footsteps.

After seeing this post last week on the Triple Pundit blog, which spells out the dilemma for the 12-year-old, Maryland-based organic tea bottler – staying true to its "no high-fructose corn syrup" label, and thus its customer base, with a Coca-Cola minority stake that's set to become more significant next year – I decided to dig into Honest Tea's application for our award for clues to their next moves.

Here's how they answered our question on their key long-term strategic goals for the organization and the workplace (my emphasis is in bold):

A critical strategic goal is to maintain our mission-driven, entrepreneurial culture as we grow alongside the world's largest beverage company, and to mentor other mission-driven companies.  We will continue our tradition of including all employees on crew drives, a vital way of instilling the Honest Tea culture.  Rapid expansion in 2010 will demand participation from everyone in the company.  Crew drives enable employees from every department to experience selling and marketing our beverages and directly invests them in our business fundamentals.  Another key goal is to maintain and build our position as a leading, innovative organic beverage company.  In 2010 we introduce Honest Kombucha, a unique, sparkling tea beverage based on live, organic cultures.  Even as we grow nationally, we are determined to sustain our role as a leader in the local community.  Honest Tea is a founding sponsor of a local environmental non-profit, Bethesda Green, supporting a healthy economy and sustainable living.  The company's visibility in the community is a source of pride for our employees and a key part of our identity.  Finally, the company's commitment to transparency, the accessibility of our President and TeaEO and the rest of the management team, are important ways in which Honest Tea will continue to be steeped in its entrepreneurial, mission-driven culture.

Like Zappos, Honest Tea is placing a premium on maintaining its human capital strategies and core values that have contributed to its massive success while it negotiates with a much larger company that has a sizable interest in it.

Related: For more on how Honest Tea's employee development strategies led it to become an industry leader, read our award profile on the firm.

In a recent post on The Wall Street Journal's The Juggle blog, Jennifer Merritt asked if Summer Fridays still exist.  The "still" part of her question is informed by the realities of the economy forcing companies to cut benefits such as a part or full workday off, and companies that are tight on staff (again because of the economy) needing all the time they can get to best serve the customer or client.

In response to Merritt's question, Summer Fridays do, in fact, still exist.  Among the nearly 500 applicants for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, 8 specifically referred to reduced hours or a full day off on Fridays during the summer in their applications:

1. The Leadership and Learning Center - consulting firm in Salem, MA
2. Sonoma Partners - software firm in Chicago, IL
3. McGraw Wentworth* - insurance benefits provider in Troy, MI
4. Family Heritage Life Insurance Company - financial services firm in Cleveland, OH
5. NogginLabs Inc - software firm in Chicago, IL
6. Maxons Restorations, Inc. - property damage restoration services provider in New York, NY
7. Rauxa Direct - advertising firm in Costa Mesa, CA
8. Affect Strategies - PR/marketing firm in New York, NY

*This company is a 2010 award finalist

In addition, a review of our 2010 applicants shows that many of them offer the following activities for employee engagement and team building on Fridays (in all seasons):

1. Happy hour
2. Healthy breakfast items – most commonly fruits and bagels
3. Staff lunch
4. Casual dress
5. Yoga
6. Massages
7. Fun run
8. "Praise Box" – measure to reward hard work with awards and prizes
9. Staff outings during sport seasons – most commonly football
10. Friday night movies

Think these Friday-themed people practices are just a waste of money?  Consider that another 2010 applicant, B2B sales training services firm Vorsight in Arlington, VA, told us that, "When we put in place our Friday company lunch and one on one coaching, top line revenue jumped 20%."

What other Friday practices do you do, or have you heard about?

I enjoyed this post by Susan Fronk on the America's Best Business Practices blog.  In it she argues that the one thing that can most positively impact your small business – over and above measures to grow revenue, cut costs, and deliver excellent customer service – is finding and keeping great employees.

She provides more value later in her article by sharing three ways small businesses can build a more productive workplace culture by attracting and retaining great employees:

• Do a good job of recruiting and hiring,
• Create a great working environment, and
• Build relationships with your employees and foster relationships among employees.

I thought I would expand upon Fronk's informative post by sharing with you some specific ways that Winning Workplaces' 2010 Top Small Company Workplace award winners find and keep great employees:

1. Hire slow.  It's not uncommon for job candidates to go through as many as 8 interviews before a hiring decision is made.
2. Hire for cultural fit.  This includes not just when a position is open, but generally when someone looks like a good fit for the organization; a number of firms prefer to keep their feelers out and plug someone in when they come across that person.
3. Grab top talent from competing firms.  Top talent is top talent, and our winning small companies are unabashed about leveraging a bad economy that has forced competing firms to shed staff to their advantage.
4. Systematize the orientation/onboarding process.  Many companies do a good job during the middle period of an employee's tenure, but few are exceptional at the beginning, a critical time for new hires.  Our Top Small Company Workplaces really excel here by doing things like mentoring and scheduling meetings with the CEO to ramp up the new employee's understanding of and commitment to the organization.
5. Managers have frequent contact with their subordinates.  For many small companies, managers only interact one on one with employees, to review performance and also their top concerns/hurdles, every three months.  Our award-winning firms typically do this every two weeks to a month.  This helps better engage employees for greater commitment, and also helps firms react to emerging issues sooner.
6. Invest in employee leadership development.  The Top Small Company Workplaces share a belief that they are best served when their top talent stays to fill and create roles of increasing responsibility, and they have seen results from their action on it including process improvement, product innovation, and better customer service – not to mention mid- and top-level employees who stay longer, keeping recruiting and training costs down.  As far as their specific leadership development strategies, see this post.
7. Give employees a voice in the decision making.  Lots of companies have an open door policy, but this no longer cuts it if you want to foster two-way communication that results in greater employee engagement and productivity.  Our award winners give their employees a voice by holding daily huddles and frequent (at least once a month) all-hands meetings.  In addition, many of them open up their books and explain the company finances so people gain a crystal clear understanding of how their role affects the top and bottom line.
8. Do employee recognition.  I've blogged before about how recognizing your staff can be meaningful and still inexpensive.  Often times a simple, face-to-face thank you or small gift personalized to the employee can make a powerful impact.
9. Be generous in providing time off.  More employers need to come to the realization that being flexible around employees' personal and family obligations makes for a more committed and productive worker.  Paid time off should be a primary consideration, but if that's not in the budget, being flexible – especially for unanticipated obligations – through measures like cross training will help immensely with retention.
10. Empower workers down to the lowest levels to make good spot decisions.  This involves a lot of trust from leaders and some additional training, but when it works it makes a dramatic impact on business results.  Just think how much happier you've been when you've called a vendor and you didn't need to be transferred up the phone/responsibility chain to have your issue resolved.  The same sense of satisfaction can mean the difference in whether your customers or clients come back to you and refer you to others.

Is there a measure you think should be in this list?  If so, I welcome your comment on it below.

Today I shared with our Twitter followers a how-to series of posts the Young Entrepreneur blog is running on starting a business.  One of these posts I found interesting is Adam Toren's piece on choosing a business legal/tax structure.  He helps budding entrepreneurs greatly by rating the pros and cons of structures including Sole Proprietorship, Joint Venture, Limited Partnership, Limited Liability Company, and C and S Corporations.

Reading Toren's post inspired me to take a look at the data Winning Workplaces has on the small business applicants for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, in terms of revenue and profitability for the legal/tax structures we looked at under our criteria of evaluating privately held and not-for-profit organizations.  The legal/tax structures of the firms we assessed included:

• C Corporation (roughly 3/10 firms)
• S Corporation (roughly 5/10 firms)
• Partnership/Proprietorship (roughly 2/10 firms)

Here's how they break down by structure for both average 2009 revenue and percentage that were profitable in 2009:

*Assumes the firm has been in business at least 3 years

The key takeaway is that while C Corps edged out the other two structures in revenue, a greater share of Partnership/Proprietorships are profitable.

You may be asking, What makes this survey sample a good one to use these metrics for benchmarking purposes?  Well, beyond the size of the sample (497 organizations) and the fact that they have all crossed the Dun & Bradstreet threshold of surviving after the first three years, most of these enterprises understand the payoff of employee engagement and team building strategies on the bottom line.  So they post better revenue and profitability numbers to shoot for than a survey sample in which employees are more likely to be actively disengaged.

What's your take on the above?  How do you see strong people practices factoring into the equation?

If you have 90 minutes to spare, I have something that's a great use of your time when it comes to expanding your understanding of the payoff of employee engagement and workplace team building activities.

Below is a video of our President's presentation last month at an Entrepreneurial Roundtable hosted by the University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

If you can't see the video in your RSS reader, click here.

The presentation kicks off with our own Gaye van den Hombergh explaining why companies should care about creating great workplaces (starting at 7:30) and the qualities we see as critical to Winning Workplaces, along with some of the people practices used by winners of our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, which were featured in the June issue of Inc. Magazine (starting at 29:00).

Starting at 44:00, Gaye led a panel featuring leaders of this year's two Chicago area winners: Marvin Klein, Founder, PortionPac Chemical Corporation; and Tom Walter, President & CEO and Tasty Catering.  As you absorb the lessons learned and insights of these two leaders, consider their workplace culture practices, which I've listed below respectively, that have led them to success – even in this tough economy:

PortionPac

Selected workplace best practices:

• Offers personal and financial support for employees on a case by case basis
• "Front to Back Day"
• Offers experience to improve personal confidence and communication skills
• Employees have a high degree of autonomy

Business results:

• 2009 revenue up 7% from 2008
• Over the same period their competitors suffered double digit losses

Tasty Catering

Selected workplace best practices:

• Personal financial crisis fund fed into by employees
• Healthy free meals provided to staff on a daily basis
• If an employee comes up with idea and is willing to put in the effort, the company will help finance and support the endeavor

Business results:

• While sales fell in 2009 vs. 2008, it experienced only half the decrease of its industry and remains profitable
• High average employee tenure of 7.5 years

What are your takeaways from watching this video?

In a post on the Business Insider blog re-posted from his own blog, GRP Partners' Mark Suster argues that leaders should solve problems and drive innovation from the top.  He writes,

I challenge you to consider whether you’re top-down or bottom up.  In analysis there are always circumstances for each approach.  But in leadership and entrepreneurism the top-down approach will be the right solution more often than not.

Now, I get that Suster is not saying that leaders should engage employees from the top down 100% of the time, but he is saying it should happen this way the majority of the time.

However, in our experience conducting employee engagement research of small businesses as part of our annual workplace award program, we see that management and decision making can happen in many different ways to lead companies to success in the metrics that ultimately matter: sales and profitability.  Our President detailed four decision-making approaches that run this gamut in these two posts.

Three of the four approaches she wrote about involve bottom-up decision making in some capacity.  And in fact, in the applications we received for our 2010 Top Small Company Workplaces award, we saw bottom-up engagement factor prominently in the qualitative feedback of some firms that are performing quite well, even in this tough economy. 

Check out four case studies that bear this out below.  All four companies have been profitable in the last three years.

Application Question: How have your organization’s people practices contributed to your top line revenue and bottom line profitability?
Response by Bronto Software
8-year-old software firm from North Carolina
2009 sales: $5.1 million; 132% 3-year sales growth
At Bronto we have a sales team who is instrumental to our success.  Because of our organic funding, growth comes from bottom up.  Employees have directly influenced consistent new client growth along with amazing client retention.

Application Question: How does the organization encourage employees to participate in important business decisions?
Response by Barhorst Insurance Group
17-year-old financial services firm from Texas
2009 sales: $6.9 million; 16% 3-year sales growth
Our organization is built on a foundation of bottom up planning!  Every year we have the branch managers provide a sales and expense plan that is fed into our annual corporate plan.  In 2008 and 2009 we completed or long term 2020 strategy to grow from 50 million in sales to 1 billion in sales.  The strategy team was comprised of 10 mid level associates from each department.  The team received feedback from their peers and developed a strategic road map for the future.  This plan includes monthly and quarterly progress reports to the leadership team.  The strategy team will begin rotating new team members through in 2010.  By using a bottom up method employees take ownership for the company's success and failure.

Response by Intermark Media
11-year-old advertising firm from New York
2009 sales: $92.7 million; 161% 3-year sales growth
At Intermark Media we believe changes in the company should be driven from the bottom up.  The employees who are interacting with our clients everyday have valuable insight into what processes work well and what changes need to be made to better meet the needs of our customers.  We encourage all employees to be a part of our decision making process at Intermark Media.  Weekly team meetings allow employees to voice opinions, discuss new ideas and solve problems.  Team leaders encourage input from each and every team member.  In addition to weekly meetings, leaders communicate daily through their email group to vote on awards, discuss ideas and concerns and get feedback.

Application Question: Over the last year, what kind of impact has the economy had on your business?
Response by Man-Machine Systems Assessment
20-year-old consulting firm from the District of Columbia
2009 sales: $8.6 million; 5% 3-year sales growth
The economy has little effect on our business.  We have continued to grow in spite of the economy and I truly believe this is because of the way we operate our business and the culture we have created.  MSA employees feel safe, and know that the owners will do everything within their power to provide work, support their needs, and care for them and their families.  This kind of loyalty is earned, and not bought.  The MSA family is strong and the support we have for one another from the top down to the bottom up allows for strength and faith as we face challenges, like the economy.

Related: We tackled bottom-up staff engagement activities in greater detail with the help of CEOs from two of our previously honored small firms in this webinar.

The following is a guest post on workplace team building and employee engagement by Steve Ritter.  Ritter, the Founder and CEO of Team Clock Institute, is the former Director of HR at Leaders Bank, which was named the #1 Best Place to Work in Illinois in 2006, and was a finalist for Winning Workplaces' Top Small Workplaces award in 2008.

Growing up, most of us are taught how to succeed as individuals.  Unfortunately, individual talent and dedication alone are not nearly enough to ensure a team’s success.  Teams are messy.  Conflict is unavoidable. Team dynamics are fluid.  Despite these challenges, working in teams is fundamental to most endeavors.

Twenty-five years ago, I began the quest of understanding the complexities of teams following a happenstance opportunity with the Chicago White Sox.  At the time, a seemingly strong team was underperforming for reasons beyond the grasp of their leadership.  Unexpectedly, a complex situation ended up having a simple solution.  Since then, identifying the recipe for healthy and effective teams has been my passion giving rise to the founding of the Team Clock Institute, a research and training consultancy specializing in breakthrough teams.  Recently, the Team Clock Institute responded to a unique challenge.

The Issue: Early in 2010, I received a call from a FORTUNE 500 company facing the integration of disparate cultures following the acquisition of a prominent player in the industry.  All of the expectable merger/acquisition politics were underway and the leadership team was seeking a simple model to anchor the transition.  What began as a casual conversation on a commuter train grew into an opportunity to assess the integration effort and provide recommendations to enhance successful business outcomes.

The Response: Accordingly, the Team Clock model was introduced to key players on the leadership team. The Team Clock model mirrors the face of a clock where each hour represents a stage along the path of team development.  In a nutshell, strong teams begin with an investment in common norms and direction.  Based on this foundation, team members test trust as they become more cohesive.  This platform supports their efforts to be innovative and take risks.  This activity inevitably leads to change and a repositioning of people and functions.  Healthy teams find a way to refocus following such growth and cycle begins again. 

The Impact: Over the next six months, the Team Clock Institute assessed a series of key business units to determine opportunities for greater effectiveness.  Results were analyzed revealing the strengths, vulnerabilities, areas of congruence and discord on the team.  Debriefing sessions were facilitated to discuss results and targeted actions were identified that would bring measurable change in team engagement and productivity.

Typical examples of diagnostic vulnerabilities included:

• Mired in loss: too depleted to re-invest.
• Inability to manage conflict/differences respectfully.
• Indulgence in the comfort zone: afraid to take risks and explore new ideas.
• Adherence to the status quo: unwilling to accept the consequences of change.

From a strengths perspective, the Team Clock Institute identified key anchors to healthy team interactions based on the diagnostic results for each team.  Goals were established in each of the core areas of vulnerability and business metrics were assigned to determine ROI.  The goal areas included:

• Investment infrastructure

- Consensus philosophy/mission/values/vision

• Trust and interactional dynamics

- Effective management of conflict

• Innovation and team effectiveness

- Measureable productivity/efficiency shifts

• Distancing to leverage change for growth

- Functional repositioning and identification of new opportunities/methodologies

The business case for effective teaming is simple.  Healthy teams are more productive and adaptable.  Anticipating the 4th quarter of the calendar year, the organization is poised to re-assess their team effectiveness metrics mapped to their productivity results.  Pending the quantitative impact, the qualitative result is clear: the emotional journey of a healthy team provides opportunities for positive workplace culture that struggling teams rarely experience.  Where is your team on the Team Clock?

Learn more about all of the resources at the Team Clock Institute at www.team-clock.com.